From Stye to Chalazion: Why Some Eyelid Bumps Harden Over Time

July 30, 2025 Ebbie Soroudi

Styes are a frequent eye health problem and can be super annoying, but they’ll usually resolve on their own with a bit of warm compress magic.

However, sometimes that innocent-looking bump doesn't just disappear like that; it lingers instead, gradually losing its redness and pain but becoming distinctively firmer and more persistent.

This transformation can signal that what started as a simple stye has evolved into something different: a chalazion.

Here’s how a common stye can turn into a chalazion and what it means for your eye health.

For instant relief from styes and chalazia, try Stye-Press Adhesive Stye Patches™ by Eye-Press. Invented by an ophthalmologist and doctor recommended, all Eye-Press products are highly affordable and available online without a prescription.

What Is a Stye?

A stye, medically known as a hordeolum, is an acute, localized infection of an oil gland in the eyelid. These glands help produce the oily component of tears that lubricate the eye and prevent tear evaporation.

There are two main types of oil glands involved: meibomian glands inside the eyelid and zeis glands located at the base of the eyelashes.

When one of these glands becomes blocked and infected, typically by bacteria like Staphylococcus aureus, a stye develops. Symptoms include:

A painful, red, and swollen bump, often resembling a pimple, on the edge of the eyelid or sometimes deeper within the eyelid
Tenderness to the touch
Swollen, red eyelid
Can come to a head, developing a small white or yellowish spot that may ooze pus if it ruptures
Feeling of irritation or scratchiness in the eye

Styes are generally self-limiting and usually resolve within a few days to a week with consistent warm compresses, which help to encourage drainage of the infected material.

What Is a Chalazion?

In contrast to a stye, a chalazion (pronounced kuh-LAY-zee-on) is a chronic, non-infectious lump that forms in the eyelid due to a blockage of a Meibomian gland, not bacterial infection. Common signs of chalazion include:

A firm, round, and typically painless lump deeper within the eyelid, often away from the very edge
Persists for weeks, months, or longer
Once mature, it is usually not red, tender, or inflamed, though it may begin with redness and swelling
Can grow large enough to press on the eyeball, potentially causing blurred vision or astigmatism

A chalazion results when the oily secretions from a Meibomian gland become thickened and trapped, causing inflammation in the form of a granuloma, a small area of inflamed tissue that becomes encapsulated by the body.

How a Stye Can Become a Chalazion

A chalazion can often be the aftermath of a stye that didn't completely heal or drain. If an oil gland becomes acutely infected and inflamed, it can lead to the painful, red bump, aka a stye.

If the stye doesn't fully drain the pus and inflammatory debris, or if the initial infection subsides but the gland's opening remains clogged, the problem shifts.

The trapped oily secretions and dead cells within the gland can no longer exit. The body's immune system responds to this retained material with a persistent, low-grade inflammatory reaction.

Over time, the body attempts to wall off this inflamed, trapped material. Fibrous tissue forms around the clogged gland, creating a firm, encapsulated lump: a chalazion. The acute infection has passed, but the chronic blockage and inflammatory response remain.
So, while not all styes turn into chalazia, a chalazion frequently develops as an internal stye that fails to resolve completely.

Why Some Eyelid Bumps Harden

Acute Inflammation: A stye initially causes significant inflammation and swelling as the body fights the infection.
Incomplete Drainage: If the blocked gland doesn't fully empty the oily secretions (sebum), it can become thicker and more waxy, trapping the material inside.
Chronic Granuloma Formation: The immune system continues to "clean up" the area, but if blockage persists, it forms a granuloma with fibrous, scar-like tissue around the trapped oil. This fibrous encapsulation is what gives the chalazion its firm, hard texture.

Risk Factors for Developing Chalazia

Chronic blepharitis
Oily skin, acne, rosacea
Poor eyelid hygiene
Recurrent styes
Medical conditions like diabetes, seborrheic dermatitis, and high cholesterol

How to Tell the Difference Between a Stye and a Chalazion

Feature	Stye	Chalazion
Onset	Acute, sudden	Gradual, often follows a stye
Pain	Painful, tender to touch	Usually painless once mature
Redness	Very red, inflamed	Less red or no redness once mature
Swelling	Localized, often at the eyelid edge	Deeper in eyelid, firm lump
Feel	Soft, may have a "head" like a pimple	Firm, rubbery, encapsulated lump
Cause	Bacterial infection of oil gland	Non-infectious blockage and inflammation
Duration	Days to a week	Weeks to months or longer

Treatment Options for a Stye

Warm Compress - Apply a clean, warm (not hot) compress to the affected eyelid for 10-15 minutes, 4-6 times a day to help liquefy trapped oil and encourage drainage.

Eyelid Massage - After applying warm compresses, gently massage the area to help express the contents of the gland.

Eyelid Hygiene - Keep eyelids clean with a mild cleanser or diluted baby shampoo.
Antibiotic Ointment or Drops - Rarely needed, but may be prescribed by a doctor if the infection is severe or spreading.

Drainage by a Doctor - In rare cases, if a stye is very large and persistent, a doctor may need to make a small incision to drain the pus.

Treatment Options for a Chalazion

Warm Compresses - May help in the very early stages of a chalazion, especially if it's still somewhat inflamed. However, once it's firm and chronic, compresses are less likely to resolve it entirely on their own.

Steroid Injection - Corticosteroid medication can be injected directly into the chalazion to reduce inflammation and shrink the lump. This is often effective for smaller chalazia.

Minor Surgery - If the chalazion is large, persistent, or affecting vision, a minor surgical procedure can be performed by an ophthalmologist to remove the encapsulated material.

When to See a Doctor

If the bump doesn’t improve after a week of consistent home care with warm compresses and hygiene.
If it grows larger rapidly, becomes extremely painful, or starts to affect your vision.
If redness and swelling spread to the entire eye or face.
If you have frequent or recurrent eyelid bumps, as this could indicate an underlying issue like chronic blepharitis.
If you’re unsure whether it’s a stye, chalazion, or something potentially more serious.

Preventing Future Eyelid Bumps

Prevention is always better than a cure, especially when it comes to eyelid bumps:

Be sure to practice good eyelid hygiene, gently washing your eyelids daily with a mild, non-irritating cleanser, diluted baby shampoo, or specialized eyelid wipes. This helps remove excess oil, debris, and bacteria that can clog glands.

Avoid rubbing your eyes with dirty hands, as this can transfer bacteria to your eyelids. If you have chronic blepharitis, rosacea, or seborrheic dermatitis, work with your doctor to manage these conditions.

Always remove all eye makeup before going to bed and replace eye makeup every three months to prevent bacterial buildup.

Instant Relief for Styes and Chalazia

A stye, while a common and often self-resolving acute infection, can sometimes take an unwelcome turn, transforming into a chalazion, a hardened, chronic lump in the eyelid.

This transition happens when the initial infection resolves but the underlying blockage and inflammation persist, leading to the encapsulation of trapped oil and debris by fibrous tissue.

While warm compresses are the primary treatment for a stye, a persistent chalazion may require medical intervention such as steroid injections or minor surgery to remove it.